Putting the T in LGBT: Understanding Trans Issues
Hi Doin' It Well,
This week I started to teach my class about Trans issues.. and they could not wrap their head around how being transgendered does NOT mean you're automatically gay. People don't realize that gender identity and sexual orientation are two different aspects of human sexuality. Would you address this topic in your article?
- E
************************
Dear E,
These are very important issues for everyone to understand, so we're very excited that you're able to discuss the distinction in your class and that you wrote in to allow us to expand this discussion. Although we've had movies like TransAmerica or the French film Ma Vie en Rose which have humanized the experiences of transgender people, most of us have trouble understanding what transgender or "trans" means.
Trans Terms
Transgender is a blanket term used to define when people's gender identity or performance differs from social expectations. This is generally defined as a continuum, ranging from individuals who occasionally engage in another gender performance to those who may live their lives fully as a different gender than assigned by society at birth, based on external genitals.
Our society has determined that there are two genders (other societies recognize more than two): masculine/man and feminine/woman. Moreover, those two genders are assumed to be connected to biological sex. But our sense of gender can be different than our biological or physical sex. Gender and sex are two different things. For some people their feelings of their gender match their biological sex. For others it doesn't. And there are lots of people and scenarios in between.
Gender Bender
Gender often includes both the societal expectations that go along with being men or women, and the performance of that gender expression. Because all gender is a performance, everyone "puts on" or "proves" their gender every day. As a challenge, try not performing gender for one day. It can be very difficult to move outside of this binary. Gender expression includes the ways that people express either masculinity or femininity. It is assumed that men will express masculinity and women, femininity. While men can do things defined as feminine and women can do things defined as masculine, there are frequently social punishments for acting outside of our presumed gender. In addition, gender, or our sense of being male or female, masculine or feminine, is different than sexual orientation.
Sexual orientation refers to who we are attracted to romantically, sexually and emotionally. Transgender folks can be straight, gay, bisexual, or lesbian. A person can be biologically a male, but present as a female and be attracted to women. The question often asked is: is this person heterosexual or lesbian? The answer is that there is no definitive answer, even though we often want one. Each person gets to decide for themselves how to categorize or label themselves. Others reject all labels and categorization. It is up to trans individuals and their partners to figure out what this may mean, if anything, for them and their relationships.
A Two-Party System?
The real question: "Why do we want so badly to have distinct categories?"
Many people may simply want clarification in an attempt to understand transgender issues. Keep in mind the continuum and wide range of gender performances and transgender identities. Here are some examples.
Transvestite generally refers to straight men who wear women's clothing. Drag queens are males performing as women and drag kings are females performing as men for entertainment. Because drag shows are popular within the LGBT communities, people often assume these people are gay, lesbian, or bisexual. For many folks, including these individuals, the identity is one that they take on and off for a variety of reasons. Transsexual individuals, on the other hand, may choose to live their entire lives in a gender other than the one they were assigned. Although some transsexual individuals choose to go through hormonal or surgical sex reassignment, they might also express their true gender in ways other than surgery.
The best way to know someone's gender identity and sexual orientation is to allow them to present them to you. When in doubt, ask! Making assumptions isn't helpful and neither is trying to categorize people into boxes with labels. Allow the individual to express themselves to you, and be respectful of the pronouns that they use to define themselves. Although many folks may use "he" or "she" to define themselves, some individuals may define themselves with gender neutral pronouns. Challenge yourself as to why you "need" to know their gender, and what that does for you.
Next week, Doin' It Well will look at what a women's center would look like in C-U.
Sex 411: Transgender Reading and Resources
Bornstein, K. My Gender Workbook
Green, J. Becoming a Visible Man
UIUC Office of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender Resources, www.odos.uiuc.edu/lgbt
Kim Rice and Ross Wantland are experts in the fields of sexuality and sexual violence prevention. Send your comments, questions, and fan mail to buzzdoinitwell@yahoo.com

