Silencing the Wrong Voices
Silence in the Courtroom
Recently you may have heard about the judge in Lincoln, Neb. who allowed a defense motion to ban the words “rape,” “sexual assault,” “victim” and “assailant” in a sexual assault trial that took place this year. The judge ordered the victim and prosecutors not to use these words, along with “sexual assault kit” and “sexual assault nurse.” The defense lawyer in the case stated that these words needed to be restricted in order to keep the trial fair. Instead, the alleged victim was allowed to use the words “sex” or “intercourse” to describe the assault.
What the F?
Can you imagine a murder trial at which the words murder, beaten, strangled, bludgeoned to death, or killed were not permitted? Of course not, because this would be ridiculous.
What does this have to do with our sex column? It led us to think about whose voices are silenced and whose are not, especially when it comes to sex.
Silence in the Classroom
For example, in our country there is no standardized curriculum of sex education to give young people the information and skills they need to become sexually healthy adults. Most states do have guidelines that say abstinence should be taught. School districts can go above and beyond the state guidelines and teach abstinence and pregnancy and STI prevention methods, but most schools do not.
Additionally, many schools limit the language that can be used in sex education. Locally, rape prevention educators are frequently discouraged from saying “sexual assault” because they can’t say the word “sex” in school.
And in those schools that do provide “really good” sex education, students receive, perhaps, a whole semester of sex ed. A whole semester. That’s what, 15 weeks, maybe an hour a week to prepare young people to understand sexuality?
There’s no consistent policy for sex education in this country. Saying the words “sex,” “condom” or “vagina” might, after all, ruin the minds of our youth.
The Loudest Voice
On the other hand, pornography, which has proliferated the Internet, is filled with Web pages that anyone can access with the click of a button. These pages promise to tell us everything that our parents, schools, friends and partners can’t. The real deal. This is a very different story about sex from what we learn in school.
Youth (and adults) crave information to help them understand what is happening and to make sense of their sexual desires and feelings. As young people are developing, and become - in a very healthy way - interested in sex and what sexuality means, they can find a host of information on the Internet to show them exactly what this country thinks of sex and how sex looks. It’s the most accessible form of sex education available today in this country.
What does it tell us? According to mainstream online pornography, sex is violent, mean, degrading (mostly towards women), doesn’t take place within any kind of relational context, and is focused on genital pleasure (of men). When we look at the language, we find that sex is racist, that women are “whores and sluts,” and men, simply “cocks.” It shows boys that their penises are weapons used to pound, slam, rip, kill, torture and bang women, all for the women’s pleasure. Because in the world of pornography this is what women love.
Makes us wanna holler
We live in a society that doesn’t allow words like “sexual assault” to enter a courtroom because it might make a sexual assault trial “unfair.” In the classroom, we restrict words like vagina, penis, sexual intercourse, sex, condom, emergency contraception and abortion because students might get the wrong impression about what our values are and what we’re teaching them about sex. We want to ensure that courtrooms are “fair” and that the minds of jurors are not tainted by hearing these words, therefore resulting in an unjust trial. To the contrary, it seems very clear where society’s values lie.
What the Fuck?
So in our society, certain voices are allowed to speak for us, to tell us what sex is and isn’t. Our concern is that very few people seem to raise their voices when rape victims are silenced in the courtroom or when sex ed is silenced in classroom, but we shy away from silencing what porn screams at us.
Good sex means sex on our own terms, and it means access to positive, healthy, accurate information about sex and sexuality. And this takes OUR voices. So scream, yell, moan, or holler, but most of all, make your voice heard.
Sex 411: Speaking Up, Speaking Out
• Promoting Awareness, Victim Empowerment: www.pavingtheway.net
• Illinois Campaign for Responsible Sex Ed: www.responsiblesexed.org
Kim Rice & Ross Wantland are professionals in the fields of sex education and violence prevention. E-mail them at buzzdoinitwell@yahoo.com